Transportation Alternatives

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Transportation Alternatives Ned Einstein: Expert testimony in public transportation accidents and incidents including bus accidents Einstein. Mr. Finally, Mr.

After receiving his Masters in Urban & Regional Planning from GWU, TA founder & President Ned Einstein began his nearly 40-year career in the passenger transportation field following a year consulting to the Illinois Department of Transportation as a consultant to the US Department of Transportation and its Urban Mass Transportation Administration (currently the Federal Transit Administration) in the transit field, and later, as a consultant to the FTA's Federal Motor Carrier Safety Association (FMCSA) in the motorcoach field, and working with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) in the schoolbus field. He began his work in the paratransit field by directing the USDOT's first nationwide study of transportation systems for elderly and disabled individuals, examining 30 systems in 18 U.S. cities, and resulting in USDOT's publication of a three-volume manual on decision-making, system design and operations authored by Mr. Einstein's focus has shifted the past two decades -- increasingly toward the provision of expert witness services -- while periodically conducting and participating in consulting efforts in almost every passenger transportation sector. Einstein's career in the past three and a half decades is likely the most unique in the entire passenger transportation field, as he has directed and participated, at the highest levels, in major projects of a national scope, in every non-rail ground transportation passenger mode or service, in addition to serving as an expert witness in more than 400 personal injury, wrongful death, labor-relations and class action lawsuits.

* In the consulting arena, many of Mr. Einstein's projects were almost legendary, including his coordination of the design and marketing efforts associated with a European-manufactured schoolbus and motorcoach exported to and sold in North America, and 10 years spent operating a 70-vehicle consolidated paratransit and non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) system; the former providing 5.0 passenger trips/vehicle service hour in two huge suburban and rural service areas, respectively. Otherwise, his consulting experiences are unique in that he is one of the few professionals in the entire field who was involved deeply in projects at the planning/system design level, the policy-making level, the operating level (particularly including training, monitoring and evaluation), in virtually every mode, and the automotive level.

* In the forensic arena, as of 2013, Mr. Einstein has participated, as an expert witness, in more than 60 lawsuits involving crossing incidents, more than 70 involving wheelchair and/or passenger securement, 20 molestation and assault cases, and hundreds of others involving transit, paratransit, motorcoach, schoolbus, special education, non-emergency medical, ambulette, taxi and shuttle services, including work on several class action and labor relations lawsuits. (See Common Accident and Incident Scenarios). This fortunate spectrum of experiences has provided Mr. Einstein with a unique perspective for a forensic expert in that he can understand, analyze and opine on almost any type of incident, involving any type of passenger, traveling in, boarding or alighting from virtually any type of non-rail ground vehicle — since he can view the incident from virtually every vantage point, and has an almost encyclopedic technical knowledge of every aspect of vehicle design, system design and operations. Further, his experiences did not merely expose him to these passengers and services. Instead, he directed or participated in high-profile projects in all these areas, and wrote nearly 200 nationally-published books, full-length papers and trade magazine articles published by organizations ranging from the U.S. Department of Transportation and National Academy of Science's Transportation Research Board to major industry trade magazines (most extensively in the schoolbus, motorcoach and transit fields). Einstein holds a few rather strong and somewhat unconventional beliefs about the performance and ingredients of success in expert witness work. While he acknowledges the importance of writing and presentation skills, and the ability to improvise, Mr. Einstein believes that the most important phase of a lawsuit is the analytical phase. He is also a proponent of the school of thought that what wins cases is not generally the brilliance of an attorney or his/her expert, or even the facts, but instead, a direct result of the level and quality of effort devoted to the case.

Non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) service lies at the bottom of the bottomless pit of the Deep State, now domi...
10/13/2026

Non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) service lies at the bottom of the bottomless pit of the Deep State, now dominated by mostly crooked brokers who do nothing but push payers around. The companies that actually provide the service earn only a small amount of this budget.





While modes like fixed route transportation only began to drift into the Deep State 60 to 70 years ago, non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) service spent its entire existence as part of the Deep State, yet for different reasons as it evolved. To be fair (to even transportation professionals)

Wheelchairs tip over largely because the rattiest service provider can obtain insurance coverage – with few questions as...
10/07/2026

Wheelchairs tip over largely because the rattiest service provider can obtain insurance coverage – with few questions asked – since when they occurred, an insurance carrier’s huge stock market losses were covered by the taxpayers.





Unless one knows better – and for the most part the only ones that do are expert witnesses and insurance carriers -- few people seem to understand how or why the sloppiest, most incompetent and often most crooked provider of public transportation service manage to find some company to insure it. I...

The single most foolish mistake I encounter regularly is the unwillingness of an attorney to let me identify the evidenc...
10/05/2026

The single most foolish mistake I encounter regularly is the unwillingness of an attorney to let me identify the evidence and fully examine it. Nowhere is this error more costly than in a case involving wheelchair securement.



As every attorney, good or bad, clearly knows, what keeps things safe is accountability. The more often a defendant is sued, the safer he, she or it will operate – at least in theory.

In different forms, the three basic modes of demand-responsive transportation – special needs schoolbus service, NEMT se...
10/01/2026

In different forms, the three basic modes of demand-responsive transportation – special needs schoolbus service, NEMT service and complementary paratransit service all suffer from a profound ignorance about efficiency and on-time performance, and these in turns translate into safety compromises – the most time savings of which is not securing wheelchairs.





While there are multiple ways to evaluate the quality of those demand responsive transportation services, the three most fundamental, and most important, are safety, reliability (measured mostly by on-time performance) and efficiency. But the three principal forms of these services play by entirely

To most public transportation professionals, compared to fixed route service (transit, schoolbus, motorcoach), paratrans...
09/28/2026

To most public transportation professionals, compared to fixed route service (transit, schoolbus, motorcoach), paratransit service (and other “demand-responsive” services) is a Rubiks cube. Current day efficiency is far lower than the best systems operating 50 years ago.



Sometimes getting the best vantagepoint from which to view things is largely a matter of luck. This was the case with me, as I got to direct the U.

Despite public transportation in the United States being horribly wasteful, and increasingly so, there have been bright ...
09/23/2026

Despite public transportation in the United States being horribly wasteful, and increasingly so, there have been bright spots periodically. Three bright spots were created by former President Gerald Ford.



Apart from the efforts of President Johnson to rescue fixed route transportation from a complete collapse, there have been precious few notable achievements in this critical part of the American society. One such President unknown for this invaluable contribution to sanity and fiscal responsibility

Most sectors of America’s public transportation system are legitimate members of the Deep State, irrespective of one’s p...
09/21/2026

Most sectors of America’s public transportation system are legitimate members of the Deep State, irrespective of one’s political position and beliefs. Fixed route transit, while not the worst, is clearly a member of this Deep State.



Many attorneys fail to file against the parties most responsible for the incident because suing only the most obvious co...
09/11/2026

Many attorneys fail to file against the parties most responsible for the incident because suing only the most obvious codefendant it the easiest path to take.





Every profession has its lazy workers – although it is a lot harder to be one on, say, a whaling ship or in a fire department. But it is much easier, and far more common, in the legal profession.

One of the most interesting, but obscure reasons why drivers do not secure wheelchairs, is that it hurts to crawl around...
09/10/2026

One of the most interesting, but obscure reasons why drivers do not secure wheelchairs, is that it hurts to crawl around on a vehicle’s flooring on their knees.

Sometimes the reasons drivers do not secure wheelchairs is simple to understand (usually the schedules are tight, and their conduct is not monitored.) Otherwise, the reasons may seem obscure.

Few public transportation agencies know how to craft a Request for Proposal that will yield the best bidder – just like ...
09/08/2026

Few public transportation agencies know how to craft a Request for Proposal that will yield the best bidder – just like few of these agencies know how to evaluate bids. That so many wheelchairs tip over is a consequence of this failure – among countless other reasons.


Next to boarding and alighting incidents – incidents that a seeing eye dog knows will not turn out well, seconds before it happens – wheelchair tipovers are, by far, the most common incident theme. They comprise more than a fifth of the more than 700 lawsuits I’ve served on as an expert.

Address

41 Hickory Hill Drive
Warwick, NY
10004

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Transportation Alternatives posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Transportation Alternatives:

Shortcuts

Share