02/23/2024
So much of our knowledge about what is happening in the world is limited to what we are told by the news media. As an attorney, whenever I hear about a newly issued legal opinion, I choose to look up and read the opinion myself. That is what I did yesterday after reading about the "frozen embryos" opinion issued by the Alabama Supreme Court. I want to share the full story of this 50 page opinion.
THE TWO SUITS:
James LePage and Emily LePage, individually and as parents of Embryo A and Embryo B, and William Tripp Fonde and Caroline Fonde, individually and as parents of Embryo C and Embryo D vs. The Center for Reproductive Medicine and Mobile Infirmary d/b/a Mobile Infirmary Medical Center
Felicia Burdick-Aysenne and Scott Aysenne, in their individual capacities and as parents of Baby Aysenne, deceased embryo/minor vs. The Center for Reproductive Medicine and Mobile Infirmary d/b/a Mobile Infirmary Medical Center
FACTUAL BACKGROUND:
Three sets of parents brought suit against The Center for Reproductive Medicine and Mobile Infirmary Medical Center seeking to recover for the wrongful death of their children. The plaintiffs had undergone IVF (in vitro fertilization) and had had some embryos implanted that resulted in the birth of healthy babies, but then contracted to have the remaining embryos kept in a cryogenic nursery located inside the hospital while they awaited future implantation. Each embryo had been artificially gestated to a few days of age and then placed in the cryogenic nursery to keep them alive at a fixed stage of development by preserving them at an extremely low temperature. A patient in the hospital managed to wander into the nursery through an unsecured doorway and removed several embryos. The subzero temperatures of the embryos burned the patient's hand, causing the patient to drop the embryos on the floor, killing them.
EACH SIDE'S CLAIMS:
The plaintiffs had asserted their wrongful death claims under Alabama's Wrongful Death of a Minor Act. The trial court granted defendants' motions to dismiss the suits, and the cases ended up at the Alabama Supreme Court following an appeal by the plaintiffs. Alabama's Wrongful Death of a Minor Act states that parents may bring a claim seeking punitive damages "when the death of a minor child is caused by the wrongful act, omission, or negligence of any person..." The act itself does not define "minor child", but this same Court held in 2011 that an "unborn child" qualifies as a minor child. Defendants were arguing that there should be an unwritten exception to that rule for unborn children who are not physically located "in utero" (inside the uterus) at the time they are killed.
COURT'S RULING:
The Alabama Supreme Court held that "unborn children are 'children' under the Act, without exception based on developmental stage, physical location, or any other ancillary characteristics." The Court also noted that even if the word "child" were ambiguous, the Alabama Constitution, Article I, Section 36.06(b), titled Sanctity of Unborn Life, would require courts to resolve the ambiguity in favor of protecting unborn life. "That section operates as a constitutionally imposed canon of construction, directing courts to construe ambiguous statutes in a way that protects the rights of the unborn child equally with the rights of born children, whenever such construction is lawful and appropriate."
DISSENTING OPINION/CONCURRING OPINION:
There was one dissenting justice who claimed that applying the Wrongful Death of a Minor Act to frozen embryos will be the end of IVF in Alabama given that frozen embryos can remain viable up to 50 years. However, another justice wrote a concurring opinion to address those allegations and stated that in the United States, IVF clinics are almost completely unregulated. They are known as the "Wild West". Whereas in the European Union countries, 96% of embryo transfers involve only two or fewer transfers at one time, thereby reducing or eliminating the need for storing embryos for extended lengths; such measures protect the lives of the unborn and still allow couples to become parents.