07/10/2026
GRABBED for Jury Duty? 🫵👩⚖️
While many of us have received a jury summons by mail, have you ever been summoned for jury duty by a police officer while you were walking down the street? Making the local news this week, a judge in Covington had sheriff's deputies bring multiple individuals walking near the courthouse to an ongoing criminal trial to report for jury duty. While the practice is uncommon, it is a practice long recognized by the Louisiana Code of Criminal Procedure.
Under Article 785(D), "In parishes other than Orleans, the judge may order the summoning of tales jurors from among the bystanders or persons in or about the courthouse." This law allows a judge, in his or her discretion, to have the sheriff summon individuals in or near the courthouse. Under what circumstances might a judge take such a step?
News reports indicate that the recent use of the statute was in a high-profile criminal r**e case. That is the kind of proceeding in which one would expect a judge to use the "tales" jury procedure. Under the 6th Amendment to the Constitution, criminal defendants have the right to a trial by jury, and they also have the right to a speedy trial. When an insufficient number of jurors report for jury duty on the day set for trial, to disband the proceeding and send everyone home threatens the defendant's constitutional rights, also subjecting the public to increased costs and the possibility that a guilty perpetrator could be set free.
Why might an insufficient number of jurors have been available at the proceeding that made the news this week? If you ask any of our judges on the Northshore, they will tell you that the number of our citizens who report for jury duty is woefully low. Jury duty is an important civic obligation. It was so important to the American founders who risked their lives to fight the British empire that they wrote, in the Declaration of Independence, that one reason for breaking from Britain was "For depriving us in many cases, of the benefits of Trial by Jury." This historical value placed on the right to trial by jury is notable.
History is knocking on our door--or our mailbox. It turns out if we don't answer that jury summons, it may grab us while we're grabbing a coffee in downtown Covington. ⚖️