06/08/2015
Fines On Financial Institutions Were More
Than $7.8 Billion In The First Quarter Of
The Year
Penalties imposed on financial institutions
totaled more than $7.8 billion in the first
quarter of 2015, up 73 percent from the prior
quarter, according to data released last
month by the Committee on Capital Markets
Regulation. There were four mega-settlements
of more than $1 billion that led the
pack. The most recent total eclipsed the
fourth-quarter 2014 clip of $4.5 billion,
which concluded a record $61.7 billion in
penalties last year, the highest recorded by
the nonprofit group since it began researching
such matters. “Data show that financial
institutions in the U.S. continue to face historically
unprecedented public financial penalties,”
the committee said in a news release.
Public financial penalties include class
action settlements that arise from suits
brought by the government and regulatory
penalties that follow enforcement actions.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
(SEC) and Commodity Futures Trading
Commission (CFTC) are typically the agencies
most active in enforcing such actions.
Many settlements reflect continued fallout
from the financial crisis. In February Morgan
Stanley paid $2.6 billion to end a U.S. Department
of Justice investigation into its mortgage-backed
securities deals. That accord,
which was the largest first-quarter deal, followed
the investment bank’s tentative $275
million settlement to resolve an SEC investigation
into subprime residential mortgage-backed
securities, (RMBS), that Morgan
Stanley sponsored and underwrote in 2007.
German financial giant Deutsche Bank AG
in April agreed to pay $2.5 billion globally—
about $2.1 billion to U.S. agencies—and
entered into a deferred prosecution agreement
to settle claims with United States and
United Kingdom regulators that its traders
helped rig the London Interbank Offered
Rate (Libor) and other key benchmarks.
Much like previous Libor settlements, no
individuals at Deutsche Bank entered a guilty
plea or were named in court documents;
however, the New York regulator forced
Deutsche Bank to terminate seven employees
and install an independent monitor.
Deutsche Bank agreed to pay $600 million to
the N.Y. Department of Financial Services,
$800 million to the CFTC, $775 million to
the Justice Department and £227 million
($357 million) to the Financial Conduct
Authority.
In February, Standard & Poor’s Financial
Services LLC also agreed to pay $1.375 billion
to settle lawsuits brought by the Department
of Justice (DOJ) and 20 attorneys general
over the rosy ratings it assigned to large securities
that turned toxic and exacerbated the
financial crisis. Additionally, Commerzbank
AG, in March agreed to enter into a deferred
prosecution agreement and to pay $1.45
billion to New York and federal regulators
and law enforcement agencies, in addition to
firing five employees implicated in the processing
of transactions for Iranian and Sudanese
entities and enabling a $2 billion fraud
at Olympus Corp.
The Cambridge, Mass.-based Committee
on Capital Markets Regulation, which advocates
improved regulation of capital markets,
consists of 36 members across finance,
investment, business, law and accounting
and academic circles. It’s led by Harvard Law
School professor Hal Scott. The research
group has previously called on the Federal
Reserve to better coordinate its stress test
rules on financial institutions required under
the Dodd-Frank Act with other regulators,
including the Federal Deposit Insurance
Corp., and with its existing stress testing
procedures.