03/14/2026
ICE had a warrant. That was why agents were able to wrench three immigrants from a South Burlington home, prompting an intense, hourslong confrontation between law enforcement and activists.
But the revelation on Thursday that the subject of the warrant wasn't in the home raises additional questions about ICE agents’ enforcement tactics and investigative competency in Vermont. It is also amplifying public scrutiny of the controversial decision by local and state law enforcement on Wednesday to assist them.
Police in Burlington and South Burlington and elected leaders across Vermont have sharply criticized the federal agents. Republican Gov. Phil Scott said in a statement Thursday that their actions showed a “lack of training, coordination, leadership, and outdated tactics” that “put both peaceful protesters and Vermont law enforcement in a difficult situation.”
Local and state law enforcement said they acted with restraint despite being pushed and spit on by activists and pelted with water bottles and clods of mud, Vermont State Police said in a statement Thursday. But local police did throw protesters to the ground in instances that were captured on video.
Vermont Public's Derek Brouwer and Peter Hirschfeld report on new details of the negotiations between local and federal law enforcement, and new calls for scrutiny from legislative leaders and the public. Photo by Zoe McDonald/Vermont Public.
https://www.vermontpublic.org/local-news/2026-03-12/ice-vermont-police-face-scrutiny-following-dorset-street-standoff