The Cream City Real Estate Company

The Cream City Real Estate Company Serving home buyers and sellers in the Greater Milwaukee/Southeast Wisconsin area since 2002. So if you are looking for a fresh approach, give us a call.

From our historic home office in Bay View, we sell homes all over the Milwaukee metro area and beyond. We are not just about the sale—we focus on becoming advocates to our clients so that they can make informed decisions through the buying or selling process. Matching the right buyer with the right home is our criterion for success. Our agents themselves span the different phases of home ownership

, so we know from personal experience how housing needs change: from that exciting first home, to that move-up dream house, through downsizing from the empty nest, to moving an aging parent to a new social environment in senior living. As agents we work collaboratively to bring an even greater depth of experience to each transaction. It makes our work fun for us, and our clients sense that energy we bring to the job. Our loyal customers have become trusted friends and raving fans, generously referring others to our company. We’d love to put our experience to work for you.

✨ New Listing✨📍3403 N 21st St, 3405Meticulously maintained and filled with character, this duplex delivers the kind of s...
05/30/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📍3403 N 21st St, 3405

Meticulously maintained and filled with character, this duplex delivers the kind of style you just can't build anymore. Nestled in a neighborhood where people invest in where they live and it shows. Both mirror-image units offer 2 large bedrooms, 1 bath, spacious living and dining rooms, original woodwork, quality hardwood floors, and stunning stained glass windows that genuinely impress. The roomy kitchen and adorable pantry make the space as functional as it is charming. The expansive & open attic brings endless potential for growth. Step outside to a sizable covered porch, or your private yard, where you will find a two-car garage, and extra parking -- room for everyone. Whether you're looking to owner-occupy or add a standout property to your portfolio, this one is the real deal.

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.
💚🔑

✨ New Listing✨📍1620 N. Hawley Rd. - $319,900.Just off the Washington Highlands this Bungalow duplex is perfect for an ow...
05/02/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📍1620 N. Hawley Rd. - $319,900.

Just off the Washington Highlands this Bungalow duplex is perfect for an owner occupant or a savvy investor. From this great location you can walk to all the restaurants and shops that Washington Heights has to offer. Spacious room sizes, beautiful woodwork and recently updated HVAC in both units. The porches on this home are spacious and perfect for summer evenings outdoors. A fresh coat of paint and refinishing some hard wood floors would make this home shine. The attic is a true walk up and expandable space for the upper unit. Perennial gardens are waiting for the avid gardener. 2 car garage on a quiet alley and an extra parking spot.

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.
💚🔑

04/25/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌S46W35820 Meadows Dr., Ottawa
4 beds | 3 baths | 2,400 SF
$699,900.

Nestled along the edge of the scenic Kettle Moraine State Forest, this meticulous home is a rare find.

✨ New Listing✨📍S46W35820 Meadows Dr. - $699,900.Nestled along the edge of the scenic Kettle Moraine State Forest, this m...
04/24/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📍S46W35820 Meadows Dr. - $699,900.

Nestled along the edge of the scenic Kettle Moraine State Forest, this meticulous home is a rare find.

Enjoy direct access to 17,000 acres of forest & cross country ski trails from your deck & patio doors-perfect for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts. This home features 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths. The inviting living room has solid hickory flooring w/ a stunning central fireplace. The bright kitchen has solid wood cabinetry and a center island, ideal for entertaining. The lower level offers an extra tall basement with abundant space for a rec room. Step outside to a large deck overlooking the backyard, complete w/ an above-ground swimming pool-perfect for summer enjoyment. Additional highlights include a detached storage garage and a 3-car attached for all of your tools and hobbies.

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.
💚🔑

If you’re thinking about making any moves this year, it’s never too early to start the conversations. Reach out and we'l...
04/23/2026

If you’re thinking about making any moves this year, it’s never too early to start the conversations. Reach out and we'll help guide you home! 🏠🔑🌷

Working with wonderful clients more than once is the greatest compliment we could ask for. Thanks, Kevin, for your trust...
04/06/2026

Working with wonderful clients more than once is the greatest compliment we could ask for. Thanks, Kevin, for your trust and review.

"After an outstanding experience with Cream City Real Estate when selling our Bay View home, we didn’t hesitate to work with them again when it came time to help my mother sell her condo. Once again, Shelly and Joan went above and beyond, delivering the same level of exceptional service, care, and expertise we had come to trust.

From start to finish, they were incredibly professional, attentive, and consistently communicative, always keeping us informed every step of the way. They were especially thoughtful and patient in working with our family, ensuring my mother felt comfortable, supported, and confident in every decision.

Their knowledge of the market and attention to detail, truly set them apart. It’s clear they don’t just focus on transactions, they build relationships to ensure the best possible outcome.

We are so grateful for their guidance, and we would highly recommend Cream City Real Estate, Shelly, and Joan to anyone looking to buy or sell a home."

✨ New Listing✨📍3353 S. Indiana Ave. - $284,900.First time on the market in over 40 years! This Milwaukee Bungalow has fr...
03/27/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📍3353 S. Indiana Ave. - $284,900.

First time on the market in over 40 years! This Milwaukee Bungalow has freshly refinished maple floors, built in buffet and quality updated main bathroom. The kitchen offers plenty of cabinets and counter tops. Rec room in lower level adds extra space with built-in bookcase, entertainment center and built-in surround sound speaker system. Gas fireplace, and a second bathroom with shower completes the lower level. Most windows updated. A/C (2025) and a newer furnace. Partially fenced yard with patio and 2 car garage. Sought after Fernwood neighborhood, close to the lake and South Shore Park. Come see it today!

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.
💚🔑🏠

03/27/2026

3353 S. Indiana Avenue.
Offered at $284,900

First time on the market in over 40 years! This Milwaukee Bungalow has freshly refinished maple floors, built in buffet and quality updated main bathroom. The kitchen offers plenty of cabinets and counter tops. Rec room in lower level adds extra space with built-in bookcase, entertainment center and built-in surround sound speaker system. Gas fireplace, and a second bathroom with shower completes the lower level. Most windows updated. A/C (2025) and a newer furnace. Partially fenced yard with patio and 2 car garage. Sought after Fernwood neighborhood, close to the lake and South Shore Park. Come see it today!

🌷 Spring is here! Our team of local, friendly experts is ready to help you make the most of this season’s market. Thinki...
03/20/2026

🌷 Spring is here! Our team of local, friendly experts is ready to help you make the most of this season’s market. Thinking about buying or selling? We’d love to chat—give us a call anytime. 🏠💐

As a proud woman-owned business, we're inspired every day by the strength, creativity, and leadership of women in our co...
03/08/2026

As a proud woman-owned business, we're inspired every day by the strength, creativity, and leadership of women in our community. Together, we're building a brighter future for all.

Happy International Women's Day!

Address

3474 S Pennsylvania Avenue
Milwaukee, WI
53207

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cream City Real Estate Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cream City Real Estate Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category