The Cream City Real Estate Company

The Cream City Real Estate Company Serving home buyers and sellers in the Greater Milwaukee/Southeast Wisconsin area since 2002. So if you are looking for a fresh approach, give us a call.

From our historic home office in Bay View, we sell homes all over the Milwaukee metro area and beyond. We are not just about the sale—we focus on becoming advocates to our clients so that they can make informed decisions through the buying or selling process. Matching the right buyer with the right home is our criterion for success. Our agents themselves span the different phases of home ownership

, so we know from personal experience how housing needs change: from that exciting first home, to that move-up dream house, through downsizing from the empty nest, to moving an aging parent to a new social environment in senior living. As agents we work collaboratively to bring an even greater depth of experience to each transaction. It makes our work fun for us, and our clients sense that energy we bring to the job. Our loyal customers have become trusted friends and raving fans, generously referring others to our company. We’d love to put our experience to work for you.

Thanks, Halle, for your feedback!💚🏡💚"My partner and I had the best first time home buying experience with Shelly from Cr...
08/07/2026

Thanks, Halle, for your feedback!
💚🏡💚

"My partner and I had the best first time home buying experience with Shelly from Cream City! Shelly is so knowledgeable and really took the time to help us learn all about Bay View houses. We felt confident that her goal was to help us find our perfect home. Her honesty and support during the process helped us feel secure in every step of making the biggest purchase of our lives. We would highly recommend her to any and all of our friends and family looking to buy! If we could do it over again, we would choose Shelly in a heartbeat."

Here's what Amy's happy client, Brian, to say about his experience working with Amy!🎉🔑🎉"We had an amazing experience wor...
08/02/2026

Here's what Amy's happy client, Brian, to say about his experience working with Amy!
🎉🔑🎉

"We had an amazing experience working with Amy Sliker at Cream City Real Estate as our buyer’s agent. She was always available for showings, incredibly easy to communicate with, and truly understood what we were looking for. Amy kept us on track and focused, making sure we found the home that was the best fit for us. What could have been a stressful process felt fun and easy with her guidance. I can’t imagine going through this journey with anyone else, and I would absolutely recommend her to anyone for your real estate needs!"

07/26/2026

Meticulous Brookfield condo. Nearly 2400 sq feet of space with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. Perfect for hosting large gatherings! First floor unit with laundry and 3 spots in the heated garage. This one won’t last! Call today and we’ll give you a private tour! Offered at $499,900

🏡✨ HOME SWEET HOME!✨🏡There's nothing quite like handing over the keys to a buyer's first home! Joshua, CONGRATULATIONS! ...
07/21/2026

🏡✨ HOME SWEET HOME!✨🏡

There's nothing quite like handing over the keys to a buyer's first home! Joshua, CONGRATULATIONS! We hope you love your new Tippecanoe home.

Amy Sliker proudly served as Joshua's buyer's agent. 💚🔑🎉

Congratulations Nikki! Bay View’s newest homeowner! Best of luck with your homeowner journey! Amy Sliker was honored to ...
07/10/2026

Congratulations Nikki! Bay View’s newest homeowner! Best of luck with your homeowner journey! Amy Sliker was honored to be her buyer agent!

OPEN HOUSE Saturday, July 11th from 11:30am-1:00pm2870 Santa Barbara Dr, Brookfield, WITastefully updated 4-bedroom home...
07/10/2026

OPEN HOUSE Saturday, July 11th from 11:30am-1:00pm

2870 Santa Barbara Dr, Brookfield, WI

Tastefully updated 4-bedroom home with spacious living areas, and great entertainment spaces! Enjoy your private backyard oasis featuring a fenced inground pool, large patio, and deck off the primary suite. In the Elmbrook school district, and great location near Wirth Park!

✨ New Listing✨📌2870 Santa Barbara Dr. - $699,900.Fall in love with this beautifully updated 4 BR Brookfield Colonial in ...
07/10/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌2870 Santa Barbara Dr. - $699,900.

Fall in love with this beautifully updated 4 BR Brookfield Colonial in the award-winning Elmbrook School District!

This tastefully updated home features a bright kitchen with granite counters, a center island, and abundant cabinetry. Enjoy a large living room with built-in cabinets and dining room. The family room with a natural fireplace and wet bar leads to the 3 season room. Upstairs are four spacious bedrooms with an updated primary ensuite and main bath. The finished basement offers additional hangout space. An expansive backyard includes a fenced inground pool with newer components. The large patio is perfect for entertaining! The newer deck connects the primary suite to your backyard oasis! Just in time to enjoy summer pool parties! Great location near Wirth Park for year round activities! Check out the list of seller updates. See it today!

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.
🔑💚🎉

07/10/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌2870 Santa Barbara Dr.
4 beds | 2.5 baths | 2,588 SF
$699,900.

Fall in love with this beautifully updated 4 BR Brookfield Colonial! Award winning Elmbrook schools!

Whether you're buying your first home, searching for your dream move-up house, downsizing, or assisting a loved one with...
06/29/2026

Whether you're buying your first home, searching for your dream move-up house, downsizing, or assisting a loved one with senior living, we understand the process from personal experience. We work together to bring a wealth of knowledge and energy to each transaction, making the journey as smooth and enjoyable as possible.

If you are looking for a fresh approach, give us a call. We’d love to put our experience to work for you.

✨ New Listing✨📍2261 N. 59th St. - $379,900.OPEN HOUSE: Sunday, June 21, 11:30am - 1:00pmThis quality bungalow is locate...
06/20/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📍2261 N. 59th St. - $379,900.

OPEN HOUSE: Sunday, June 21, 11:30am - 1:00pm

This quality bungalow is located just off Elliott circle in a quiet neighborhood. Offering 5 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this home is filled with thoughtful updates and timeless charm. Step into the spacious, sun-filled entryway that welcomes you inside. The inviting living room and cheerful dining room feature a built-in buffet and beautiful original hardwood floors that extend throughout the main level. The kitchen has a center island and a dishwasher with all appliances included. Two bedrooms and a full bathroom complete the first floor. Upstairs, you'll find a generously sized primary bedroom with a walk-in closet, along with two additional bedrooms and a versatile office space--perfect for working from home.

The yard is private and perfect for your summer backyard gatherings.

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.
🏠🔑🌿

Address

3474 S Pennsylvania Avenue
Milwaukee, WI
53207

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cream City Real Estate Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cream City Real Estate Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category