04/04/2025
One of the great myths pushed by the medical industry lobbyists is that if damage award caps were raised, doctors would leave Louisana. So we have to keep them at the level they were set in 1975 where, for example, the maximum they have to pay in a death case resulting from malpractice is $100,000.00. It's not true.
The imposition of damage caps on victims of medical malpractice crippled or killed has nothing to do with doctor populations.
Don't believe it? Seem counter-intuitive? Look it up: Becker's Hospital Review (2024).
The top ten primary care doctor patient ratios were as follows: The District of Columbia, Rhode island, New York, Massachusetts, Vermont, Maryland, Oregon, Connecticut, Hawaii and Minnesota. Of those top ten states, only two (Oregon and Hawaii) have med mal caps.
By contrast, Texas and Mississippi have caps on damages like Louisiana in med mal cases. They rank 47th and 44th in primary care doctor/patient ratios. Louisiana ranks 25th.
It's a myth. Just like the one about caps keeping medical malpractice insurance rates down. In 1975, Louisiana was ranked 25th in cost according to then Insurance Commissioner Sherman Bernard in testimony before the Legislature when the law was enacted. Today, with a bottom-dollar low cap, Louisiana ranks #8 in med mal insurance costs according to the Cunningham Group, a national insurance agency for doctors seeking med mal insurance.
One thing Louisiana's med mal caps do for sure. They crush med mal victims and their families who have suffered life-altering, catastrophic injuries and death.
So when someone tells you we need med mal caps in Louisiana to keep doctors here or insurance costs down, clue them in. It's industry propaganda to impose on the people for profits and not true.