Florida Keys and Key West Properties

Florida Keys and Key West Properties REALTOR® with Coldwell Banker Schmitt, Nancy Hershoff works with residential and commercial buyers and sellers throughout the Florida Keys and Key West.

About Nancy

As a native Floridian, Nancy Hershoff has an in-depth understanding of the Florida Keys community. She uses her knowledge and expertise to assist her customers in finding their perfect piece of paradise. A graduate of Nova Southeastern with a Master’s Degree in Administration, Nancy worked at a law firm for over eleven years before making a career move into real estate. Being of positive nature, Nancy is enthusiastic about everything she does. A true people person, she is highly involved in her community and is an engaged member of the Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon and Lower Keys Chamber of Commerce, as well as, actively participating in many fundraising events for local charities including Fishermans
Hospital, Mariners Hospital and Baptist Health of South Florida to name a few. She is also a board member of the Florida Keys Hurricane Recovery Foundation which is helping residents who were hit hard after Hurricane Irma. Nancy is married to Jay Hershoff, a prominent local attorney in Tavernier. Together they enjoy visiting their children and grandchildren, fishing, boating, and getting together with friends.

Here's the current inventory for Islamorada. This metric represents how many homes are on the market right now.
09/22/2026

Here's the current inventory for Islamorada. This metric represents how many homes are on the market right now.

09/21/2026

You don’t need to gut the kitchen to get buyers to fall in love. ✨

Swapping hardware, adding open shelving, a fresh light fixture — these are the kinds of updates that quietly do the heavy lifting.

Buyers don’t remember every square foot, they remember how a space made them feel.

If you’re thinking about selling and wondering where to even start, that’s exactly what I’m here for.

Let’s figure out what’s actually worth doing (and what isn’t).

Give me a call and let’s start the conversation.

Nancy Hershoff | 305-393-4061
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.

floridakeyshomesearch islamorada islamoradahomes islamoradarealestate

09/20/2026

A pop of color can bring a whole space to life! 🍂 This warm combo of earthy browns and vibrant yellow adds personality, depth, and instant charm. Thinking of selling? Strategic design choices like this can make your home unforgettable. 🏡💛

09/18/2026

Views lead to tours. Tours lead to offers. Let's make sure your home is being seen by the right buyers.

09/17/2026

Rates are up and the temptation is to sit on your hands and wait for a “better number.”

Here’s the thing: the right property in the Keys doesn’t wait for you.

If it fits, it fits — the rate is a detail you can revisit later.

Let me connect you with a local lender so you can see what actually makes sense for your situation right here and now.

Give me a call and let’s get the conversation started.

Nancy Hershoff | 305-393-4061
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.

floridakeyshomesearch islamorada islamoradahomes islamoradarealestate

Buying your first home can be daunting, but it's always easier with an expert in your corner! Here's a top-level checkli...
09/16/2026

Buying your first home can be daunting, but it's always easier with an expert in your corner! Here's a top-level checklist for finding your dream home.

09/14/2026

Luxury isn't a word, it’s a feeling. Ready to experience the difference for yourself?

09/14/2026

How big of a home do you actually need? 🏡

Before you start scrolling listings, sit with these 5 questions first:

1️⃣ Is this your forever home, or good enough for right now?
2️⃣ What will your income look like down the line?
3️⃣ Will you entertain a lot or host many guests?
4️⃣ How much space do you want from family members?
5️⃣ Does the home feel spacious, regardless of square footage?

Square footage is just a number — how a home feels to live in is what actually matters.

Answer these honestly and the right size starts to answer itself.

Reach out with any buying or selling questions you may have! 📲

Nancy Hershoff | 305-393-4061
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co.

floridakeyshomesearch islamorada islamoradahomes islamoradarealestate

On a scale of 1-10 how important is a home office to you? 💼
09/12/2026

On a scale of 1-10 how important is a home office to you? 💼

If you want top dollar, you have to prep like a pro. 🧼🛠 Declutter, fix the little stuff, and consider staging. A polishe...
09/10/2026

If you want top dollar, you have to prep like a pro. 🧼🛠 Declutter, fix the little stuff, and consider staging. A polished home grabs more attention—and better offers.

Address

85990 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL
33036

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Florida Keys and Key West Properties posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category