09/12/2026
The optics look bad, as they say…..
U.S. Magistrate Judge Kathleen Kay of the Western District of Louisiana and William Monk, representing the plaintiff, had a years-long close friendship before the case was referred to her.
"At best, this disclosure was incomplete," wrote Fifth Circuit Judge James Graves Jr., joined by Judge Carl Stewart.
In dissent, Judge Andrew Oldham wrote that the Port of Lake Charles' lawyers made a "Hail Mary pass" to undo the judgment.
Latham & Watkins partner Greg Garre argued at the Fifth Circuit for plaintiff IFG Port Holdings, while Adams & Reese counsel Michael H. Rubin argued for the Port of Lake Charles.
From reporter Avalon Zoppo: 🔗 https://www.law.com/nationallawjournal/2026/09/09/windfall-verdict-wiped-5th-circuit-undoes-124m-award-over-judge-lawyer-friendship/