04/30/2026
Report: 1 in 5 Homebuyers Receive Suspicious or Fraudulent Communication During Closing
April 28, 2026
A new report from CertifID shows that fraud has moved from a behind-the-scenes threat to a front-of-mind concern for homebuyers and sellers. The findings suggest that security is no longer an operational issue alone. It is now a core part of the customer experience.
The 2026 State of Wire Fraud Report draws on survey data from more than 1,400 consumers and real estate professionals, along with transaction-level insights. It paints a picture of an industry where fraud attempts are common and expectations around protection are rising quickly.
Nearly one in four homebuyers (22%) reported receiving a fraudulent or suspicious communication during their closing process. At the same time, consumer awareness has reached a tipping point. More than 80% of respondents said they are aware that criminals use artificial intelligence to impersonate trusted parties in real estate deals. As fraud tactics become more sophisticated, consumers are becoming more cautious and more selective.
That shift is changing behavior in ways that directly impact title and settlement professionals. According to the report, 68% of consumers said guaranteed protection from wire fraud strongly influences which provider they choose. In addition, 85% said they would be willing to pay more for that protection.
However, the data also reveals a troubling gap between awareness and action. Many consumers recognize suspicious activity but do not know how to respond effectively, leaving them vulnerable even when they sense something is wrong. A third of consumers who received suspicious communications either ignored them or took no action at all
The report also highlights the lasting damage caused by fraud incidents. More than half of consumers said they would not work with a title company or real estate firm again after experiencing wire fraud, even if their funds were fully recovered. This underscores that the impact extends beyond financial loss to long-term trust and reputation.
The report also points to the growing influence of artificial intelligence in fraud schemes. Attackers can now generate highly convincing emails, clone voices and mimic trusted parties with greater accuracy. As a result, traditional warning signs are becoming harder to detect. Last year, fraud analysts estimated 40% of business email compromise phishing emails were AI-generated. According to CertifID’s study, there has been a 1,760% year-over-year increase in business email compromise attacks since generative AI tools became widely available. For title professionals on the front lines, they see the change clearly. In survey, 72.6% report that fraud attempts are becoming more sophisticated, 60.1% say fraud attempts are increasing in frequency and 57.5% encounter suspicious activity quarterly or more frequently.
Verifying wire instructions through trusted channels, setting expectations with consumers early and reinforcing secure communication practices throughout the transaction are increasingly essential. The data suggests the industry is at an inflection point. Fraud is not only increasing in frequency and sophistication, but also shaping how consumers evaluate service providers. For title companies, that means security is no longer just about avoiding loss. It is about earning trust.
In its report, CertifID shared the story of Sarah Dombrowski, who has worked in title for 27 years. In March 2022, she opened her own company, Unique Title and Escrow. She thought she was protected: she had fraud prevention tools in place. Then came the phone call.
On Aug. 7, 2024, an employee told her a mortgage payoff wire hadn’t arrived. $311,785 was missing.
“I felt like I was dying, Dombrowski recalled. "My chest was tight, my heart was racing. It’s like hitting a Mack truck at 60 miles per hour.”
Her first concern was her clients. Then came the terrifying realization: her business, her livelihood and her team. Everything was in jeopardy. She barely slept for weeks. Insurance companies and attorneys offered no guidance.
The product she had trusted? They told her to call her bank.
CertifID Fraud Recovery Services eventually helped return most of the stolen funds, but the experience left a permanent mark. Dombrowski now operates differently with verified processes in place for every wire.
“I can close my eyes at night knowing I will not experience wire fraud again, she said. I don’t want to be in cybersecurity. I want to focus on title.”