Bieniek Law, P.C.

05/01/2026

Investing in the Next Generation. 🏛️⚖️

Had a wonderful time yesterday evening attending the Greencastle Elementary Career Fair. It was a privilege to represent the legal profession and speak with so many curious students about what it means to be a lawyer right here in our community.

Admittedly, the competition was stiff! It’s hard to make a legal case for paperwork and advocacy when the Fire Department and Sheriff’s Deputies are letting kids test out the sirens and explore their vehicles right outside. 🚒🚓

However, our firm’s station held its own—turns out, you can never go wrong with a stash of candy and some high-quality animal erasers! 🍬✏️

On a more serious note, we are passionate about the future of legal services in our rural areas. We need dedicated men and women who are willing to work, live, and advocate in small towns. If we inspired even one student to consider a future in the law last night, we consider it a win for the entire community.

Thank you to the staff at Deer Meadow, Ridpath, and TZ for hosting such a great evening event!

04/16/2026

Bieniek Law is proud to be part of the Emerald Palace rebuild at Robeann Park.

Community isn’t just about where you work. This week, Scott isn’t just behind a desk, he’s on site trading his suit for a tool belt. While Bieniek Law was honored to have donated equipment for the new structure, Scott felt it was important to get his hands dirty and contribute some manual labor to the build.

For Scott, this project is personal. The Emerald Palace has been an incredible asset for his own children over the years, providing a space for imagination, exercise, and friendship. He is deeply grateful for the opportunity to help ensure that the next generation of kids in our community gets to enjoy those same core memories in a safe, beautiful new space.

A huge thank you to all the organizers and volunteers making this happen! We can’t wait to see the finished palace and hear the sound of kids playing there once again.

04/01/2026

This cautionary tale from the Court of Appeals of Indiana serves as a vital reminder that when it comes to growing your family, good intentions are no substitute for legal protection.

In the recent case of Olbera v. Sykes, the court had to untangle a complex situation involving a same-sex marriage and a biological father.

The Case at a Glance

A same-sex couple, Tiara and Nicole, wanted to have a child. They reached an agreement with a male friend, Demaj, who moved in with them. After several attempts, Nicole became pregnant by Demaj through consensual sexual in*******se.

Tiara and Nicole married shortly before the birth, believing the marriage would automatically make Tiara the legal parent. However, after the couple separated, a legal battle ensued between the spouse (Tiara) and the biological father (Demaj).

The Court's Ruling

The Court of Appeals ultimately ruled in favor of the biological father, reversing a previous trial court decision. Key takeaways from the ruling include:

In*******se vs. Artificial Insemination: Indiana law is clear—you cannot legally be a s***m donor if the child is conceived through in*******se. Legally, that makes you a father, not a donor.

The "Marital Presumption" is Rebuttable: While same-sex spouses are entitled to the same legal presumptions as opposite-sex spouses, those presumptions can be defeated by direct, clear, and convincing evidence—such as biological paternity in the absence of a valid donor agreement.

No Formal Agreement: Because there was no physician-led artificial insemination and no written agreement where the father voluntarily relinquished his rights, his parental status remained intact.

The Moral of the Story

If you are exploring alternative ways to conceive, consult with a family law attorney first. Simply having a friend come over to do the deed does not protect your parental rights or clarify the donor's lack thereof. Without the proper legal framework—including formal artificial insemination and ironclad contracts—you may find yourself in a years-long custody battle.

Don't leave your family's future to chance. Get legal advice before you begin. We can help.

03/17/2026

A few weeks ago, I reached out to each of our local school corporations with an offer to sponsor two teachers from each district to attend the Indiana Civics Summit & Educator Convening. I believe that empowering our educators with the best tools is the most effective way to inspire the next generation of informed citizens.

Cloverdale Middle School was the first to take me up on this offer.

While Principal Chelsey Meluch shared the wonderful news that the Indiana Bar Foundation is now covering the registration and transportation fees for the attending teacher, I didn’t want that to stop the momentum. I am honoring my original commitment by pivoting those funds into a direct donation to Cloverdale Middle School.

These funds will allow the attending teacher to bring the Summit’s lessons to life by purchasing new civics materials and resources for their classroom.

In today’s national and local political climate, understanding the foundations of our democracy has never been more vital. I am proud to support Cloverdale in leading the way!

If you are a teacher at one of the other school corporations, please reach out. I would love to see more teachers take advantage of this opportunity.

02/27/2026

🏆 Big News at Bieniek Law!

We are thrilled to announce that Scott Bieniek has been named a 2026 Super Lawyer!

This honor is a testament to Scott’s unwavering dedication to his clients and his pursuit of legal excellence. Whether he’s navigating the complexities of family law, defending the rights of his criminal clients, or fighting for justice in personal injury cases, Scott brings a level of passion and expertise that truly sets him apart.

What Does it Mean to be a "Super Lawyer"?
Being named a Super Lawyer is more than just a title—it is an elite distinction held by no more than 5% of attorneys in the state.

Scott was selected through a multiphase process designed to identify the best of the best. This rigorous evaluation includes:

Peer Nominations: Candidates are nominated by other lawyers who have personally observed them in action.

Independent Research: The Super Lawyers research team evaluates candidates on 12 indicators of professional achievement, including verdicts, experience, and community service.

Blue Ribbon Panel: Top-scoring candidates undergo a final review by a panel of highly-ranked peers in their specific practice area.

Rooted in Putnam County
For Scott, practicing law isn’t just about the courtroom—it’s about the community. A proud resident of Greencastle, Scott is deeply invested in the place he calls home. When he isn’t at the office, you’ll likely find him:

Serving the Community: As a dedicated board member for both the Putnam County Community Foundation and Cummins Behavioral Health, Inc.

On the Field: Giving back as a volunteer coach with the Greencastle Youth Softball Association.

At Home: Spending quality time with his wife and their five daughters.

Scott’s commitment to his family and his neighbors is the same commitment he brings to every case. We couldn’t be prouder of this well-deserved recognition!

Join us in congratulating Scott in the comments below! 👇

02/27/2026

They say if you love what you do, you’ll never work a day in your life. But the truth is, some days are incredibly heavy. Then, I receive a note like this, and it reminds me exactly why I stepped into this profession.

Results are great, but providing a family with peace and the "tough advice" needed to get there? That’s the real win. Thank you for trusting me to guide you through the storm.

Moments like these are why I do what I do.

"Dear Scott ,

Thank you for everything you have done for me, [my son], and [my husband]. There are no words to fully express my gratitude. You gave me something no one else ever has: peace.

I truly appreciate you sticking by me and offering the tough advice I needed to hear. You are wise beyond your years and represent the kind of justice we need more of. Thank you for your patience, for teaching me poise, and for ensuring that time was on my side.

This is a huge win for [my son]!

You are the GOAT!!!

[Client], [my son], and [my husband]"

02/20/2026

One of my favorite events of the year and a great way to start each year’s race season. Proud to support this event and participate with the family. Hope to see you there.

10/29/2025

The Lady Tiger Cubs volleyball team is going to Semi-State!!!

Bieniek Law is proud to support the team by purchasing tickets for the first 40 Greencastle high school students that want to ride the FREE fan bus on Saturday to support the team.

Sign up during your lunches and help our ladies continue their remarkable run through the state tournament.

Greencastle High School Greencastle Athletics

10/28/2025

The day we wait for all year is almost here! 🥳

Bieniek Law is so excited to sponsor Trick-or-Treating on the Courthouse Square again this year!

Bring your little ghosts and goblins to the square on Halloween from 4:00 PM to 6:00 PM for a safe and fun night of treats. We hope to see you there!

🎃👻 Get ready for a spooktacular night in downtown Greencastle!

Join us for our annual Downtown Trick-or-Treat — where 25+ local businesses and non-profits will hand out candy, host fun activities, and fill the square with Halloween magic. 🏙️🍬

✨ When: Friday, October 31st
🕓 4 - 6pm
📍 Where: Courthouse Square and Downtown Greencastle

Bring your costumes, your friends, and your Halloween spirit — it’s free, family-friendly, and open to everyone!

Thanks to our sponsors!
Bieniek Law, P.C.
Abstract & Title Guaranty Co., Inc.

10/22/2025

Indiana is facing a critical attorney shortage, especially in our rural counties. As a member of the Board of Governors for the Indiana State Bar Association, I've been actively involved in developing a strategic plan to address this issue and increase the number of attorneys serving these underserved areas.

It was incredibly encouraging to recently host a bright high school freshman who expressed an interest in attending law school! It's conversations and connections like these that remind me of the importance of our work and the potential for the next generation to make a real difference. We need to inspire and support aspiring legal minds to consider careers in public service and rural practice.

I want to thank Judge Headley and Judge Bridges for allowing him to observe proceedings. And Prosecutor Austin Malayer for speaking to him at lunch.