09/02/2026
That was crazy. Hearing about it for the first time
Former Michigan Lawyer Gets 18 to 40 Years for Killing Friend After Dog-Ransom Joke
HOUGHTON, Mich. — A former Upper Peninsula attorney will spend at least 18 years in prison for killing a friend in a saloon bathroom — a shooting that reporting on the case links to a joke about holding the lawyer’s dog for ransom. Evan Andrew Dixon, 62, was sentenced Monday, Aug. 31, for the November 2023 killing of Theron Duncan, 53.
Judge Matthew Wiese imposed an 18-to-40-year sentence in Houghton County Circuit Court. Dixon pleaded no contest to second-degree murder in June under an agreement dismissing first-degree murder and felony-fi***rm charges. Prosecutor Dan Helmer said Duncan’s family was consulted about the agreement.
The killing occurred Nov. 13, 2023, inside the men’s restroom at the Douglass House Saloon in downtown Houghton. Prosecutors said the men had been drinking before a disagreement escalated. According to People’s account, Duncan had joked about holding Dixon’s dog for ransom; a bartender later told Dixon that Duncan had been joking.
At sentencing, Dixon spoke emotionally and described Duncan as a friend. “I can’t change what happened,” Dixon said, according to TV6’s courtroom reporting. “I can’t even explain what happened.” He apologized and said he had harbored no ill will toward Duncan.
Duncan’s family described the everyday contact the shooting permanently ended. His mother, Helen Galang, recalled receiving messages from her son on the day he died. His daughter, Chinea, described a loving father and grandfather whose absence would be felt by children who knew him and an unborn grandchild who never would.
Wiese acknowledged Dixon’s remorse but delivered a blunt assessment: “Mr. Duncan should not be dead.” The judge added, “And he’s only dead because you killed him."
Wiese, a Marquette County judge, handled the case after local judges stepped aside because of their professional connections to Dixon.
Dixon received credit for 1,023 days already served and was ordered to pay restitution for Duncan’s funeral and cremation expenses. The sentence closes a prosecution that lasted nearly three years after the fatal shooting.
By: Tom Manke
Sept.1, 2026
Booking Photo