09/03/2026
Does a majority-woman jury change the odds of an NGRI verdict?
In the Lindsay Clancy case, the jury’s gender makeup has sparked a bigger question: could having a majority-woman jury matter when the defense is arguing Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity (NGRI)?
There’s research on gender differences in attitudes toward mental illness, criminal responsibility, and punishment, but what do the numbers actually tell us?
And more importantly: could those differences translate into a different outcome at trial?
We’re breaking down the gendered statistics, what they can—and can’t—tell us about this jury, and why NGRI cases are so difficult to predict.
Would you expect a majority-woman jury to be more receptive to an insanity defense?