09/17/2026
🧊 IT LOOKED LIKE A WINTER ACCIDENT - THEN WE FOUND THE WATER MAIN 🧊
We picked the jury. We gave our opening statement. And before Day 2 of trial began, the case resolved for life-changing money.
At first glance, it looked like a winter car crash.
Except it wasn't snowing. It wasn't sleeting. It wasn't raining. Certified weather records showed no precipitation that morning.
Multiple crashes. No one was ticketed.
Our client was a pedestrian pinned between two vehicles in one of those crashes, suffering a devastating femur fracture that required surgery and the placement of a metal rod and screws in his leg.
What was happening? Multiple vehicles were crashing on the same massive sheet of ice. Police documented repeated crashes, called for salt, and ultimately dealt with ice covering multiple lanes of Hall Street. The responding officer documented a “large area of ice” covering the northbound and continuous turn lanes.
So Partner David Nelson and his trial team started digging. Co-counsel Bevis Schock was with us as the case moved toward trial, and our team spent years assembling what had actually happened.
We reconstructed the events using years-old Water Division records, work orders, police reports, radio traffic, City procedures and deposition testimony. We established that:
💥 water from a leaking City water main had made its way onto Hall Street, where freezing temperatures turned it into a massive sheet of ice;
💥 the City knew about a leaking water main two weeks before our client was injured; and
💥The City's traffic control diverted motorists directly into the resulting sheet of ice.
We uncovered gaps in the City's own documentation about who was there, when warnings were placed, where they were placed, and how traffic control was monitored as conditions worsened.
Then we used the City's own witnesses, records and rules to build the case.
The City tried to keep the case from ever reaching a jury. We fought that, and won.
Days before trial, it tried to shift responsibility to a contractor. We fought that, and won again. The late attempt to shift blame to the contractor was barred before trial.
By the time we stood in front of the jury, this wasn't a case about bad weather anymore.
It was about a known danger, a preventable risk, and a system that failed to protect the public.
We were ready to keep fighting. But our client is the boss. When the opportunity to resolve the case was placed in front of him, the decision was his to make.
He made it. At Nelson & Nelson, we work hard for hardworking people. We investigate deeper. We prepare relentlessly. We stand ready to take the fight to a jury and we never lose sight of who we're fighting for.
The leak may have been an accident. The 14-day delay to repair it was a decision. We did the work to prove the difference.