08/12/2026
The Supreme Court of Maryland answered a jurisdictional question in July that decides whether a District Court protective order case gets one appeal or two.
Walston v. Lindsay, No. 38, September Term 2025, filed July 17th. Opinion by Justice Booth. A father obtained an interim, then a temporary, then a final protective order in the District Court against the mother on behalf of their child. The mother noted a de novo appeal to the circuit court. While that appeal was pending she asked for and received two continuances, and the circuit court entered an intervening protective order each time to hold the position.
She then tried to appeal further, to the Appellate Court of Maryland. The theory was that entering those intervening orders was an exercise of the circuit court's original jurisdiction, which would take the final judgment outside section 12-302(a) of the Courts and Judicial Proceedings Article and open a second appeal.
The Court rejected it. Issuing an intervening protective order during a pending de novo appeal did not convert the circuit court's role from appellate to original, and no additional right of appeal followed. The judgment of the Circuit Court for Montgomery County was affirmed.
The practical lesson is unglamorous and expensive to learn late. In a District Court protective order case, the de novo appeal to the circuit court is where the record gets made and where the case usually ends. Try it as though there is nothing after it, because most of the time there is not.