10/09/2026
The most expensive sentence in a criminal case is often βI have nothing to hide.β
Picture a man in Schenectady. A detective calls him. Friendly voice. βJust need to clear a few things up. Wonβt take long.β
Heβs innocent, so he goes in. He answers every question for two hours. Somewhere in there he gets a time wrong, then corrects it, then adds a detail he forgot the first time.
None of that is lying. Itβs what memory does under stress. But on paper it reads as two versions of the same story.
I spent years as a prosecutor in Queens. When a statement landed on my desk, I read it looking for gaps. Not because people are liars, but because honest people are rarely perfect witnesses, especially when theyβre scared.
If police want to talk to you, hereβs a line that works:
βIβm happy to cooperate, but I want to speak with a lawyer first.β
Itβs polite. Itβs short. It doesnβt make you look guilty. It makes you look careful.
Then call a lawyer before you call anyone else, including the friend who βknows a guy at the department.β If it turns out talking makes sense, a lawyer can set the terms: which topics, how long, and whether he sits next to you.
You can always agree to an interview later. You can never take back one you already gave.
Has anyone in your circle learned this the hard way?
Find Me Online
Website: https://babcockdefense.com/
Google Map: https://www.google.com/maps?cid=1000104335702761627
Avvo: https://www.avvo.com/attorneys/12211-ny-robert-babcock-928017.html
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/bob-babcock-a92543354/