10/23/2020
Earlier this year, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) decided Shak vs. Shak, a case about the limits that can or cannot be placed on parties' free speech rights when it comes to talking openly - and particularly on social media - about their ongoing family law proceedings.
In that case, the parties had been posting publicly and negatively about their divorce on social media. In response to an argument that those posts could cause future harm for the parties' young child, the trial court entered what is called a "nondisparagement order" which prohibited the parties from posting negatively about the other on social media, at least until their child turned fourteen years old. Once the case made its way to the SJC, the SJC found that the trial court order was actually a violation of the parties' First Amendment right to free speech.
"The best solution would be for parties in divorce and child custody matters to rise above any acrimonious feelings they may have, and, with the well-being of their children paramount in their minds, simply refrain from making disparaging remarks about one another,'' the SJC said in Shak v. Shak. We couldn't agree more.
The Shak decision does not impact the ability of parties to enter into a nondisparagement agreement voluntarily, and our practice is to include nondisparagement language in nearly every agreement. But note that, under Shak, it is unlikely that a Court would hold a party in contempt for violating a nondisparagement provision, because the Court does not want to be seen as violating a parties' First Amendment right to free speech.
If you and your former spouse or co-parent are parenting simply by verbal agreement, we strongly recommend reducing your agreement to writing and having it entered as an Order of the Court. For assistance in doing so, please contact us at (978) 263-4160 or visit us online at www.foleymacadiepc.com. We look forward to being of assistance!
Family law attorneys with 40+ years experience. Let us help you embrace a new day . Now offering free telephone consultations!