02/07/2026
The Supreme Court of the Philippines, in ### v. People of the Philippines (G.R. No. 274842, October 22, 2025), affirmed the judgment of conviction against the accused for violation of Republic Act No. 9262 (Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act), arising from the publication of derogatory and threatening statements on the social media platform Facebook.
In disposing of the accused's defense of identity theft and the purported creation of a "dummy" profile by an unauthorized third party, the High Tribunal established a binding evidentiary standard, ruling that the prosecution cannot rely solely upon the prima facie appearance of a user's name or profile likeness; rather, it bears the burden to establish actual ownership, access, or constructive control over the digital account.
To govern the admissibility and weight of electronic evidence in establishing digital authorship, the Court promulgated seven jurisprudential guideposts.
Finding that the prosecution's evidence satisfied a combination of these criteria, specifically through a historical pattern of targeted communication, unique personal knowledge of the victim's social media restrictions, and consistent user engagement, the Court rejected the respondent's alibi and sustained the penalty of up to eight years of imprisonment, a fine of PHP 100,000, and mandatory psychological counseling.
Link to full article in the comment section.