Informed Paralegal Services

Informed Paralegal Services NOT LAWYERS! ⚖️

Licensed, insured, and affordable. Serving Alberta, Saskatchewan (Limited Licensing Pilot), and B.C. (Innovative Sandbox).

Email [email protected] for an estimate.

For real tho ⚖️🤓
03/17/2026

For real tho ⚖️🤓

An Alberta judge has divided up a group of cats between two feuding former spouses, saying neither gets to keep all of t...
01/18/2026

An Alberta judge has divided up a group of cats between two feuding former spouses, saying neither gets to keep all of them because - in Alberta at least - pets aren't the same as kids and legally shouldn't be treated as such.

"Parenthood and pet ownership should not be conflated," Justice Douglas Mah said in a written judgment last month in a case registered in Fort McMurray.

"The legal test applicable to determining parenting after separation should be different than that for deciding the placement of pets after separation."

According to the judgment, Singh and Smith lived together for about six years but separated in March 2023. They acquired four cats together. Salem came from an online advertisement. Diablo was acquired from the SPCA. Zora and Samara were both rescued as strays.

The turning point came when Smith left the home after a heated dispute. When Smith returned the following day to retrieve her belongings, Mah wrote the cats were gone and had been "crated up and spirited away by Mr. Singh”.

She sued and got them back, only to have him file a counterclaim, leading to a lower court trial in November 2024 that resulted in each getting two cats. The trial judge at the time said both parties were capable of caring for the cats, and she couldn't say who they'd be better off with.

Singh appealed the case to Mah in Court of King's Bench, and both sides argued they should keep all four felines, as that was in the best interests of the pets.
Mah, in his judgment, acknowledged that considering "the best interests of the cat" may be gaining a legal foothold in other jurisdictions, but said the concept has no bearing in Alberta and left each with two cats.
He said he declined an argument by Singh to take "a more enlightened and cat-forward approach" in line with evolving societal values.

He also said that using the term "best interests" in reference to pets anthropomorphizes them. Mah wrote the child test is different than the pet test for custody because "the sole job, function and duty of a parent is to provide the foundation for a successful life for the parent's child”.

“On the other hand”, he wrote, "it is indisputable that pets are property. Further, the purpose of pet ownership is companionship."

Mah wrote that while society doesn't condone mistreatment or cruelty to animals, whether someone can demonstrate that they are capable and willing to properly care for a cat or other pet should be, and is, a factor in determining ownership of a pet.

He said society also recognizes that dogs and cats are able to feel emotions and may form real bonds with people and peer animals, which means it is also a factor when pet ownership is disputed. But, he said, "there must be an evolutionary line drawn somewhere”.

"I hope that does not sound harsh or that I am anti-animal rights. But apart from animal welfare laws, I don't think the court should be concerned with inquiring into the emotional life of pets in the order of hamsters, parrots, reptiles, and tropical fish in determining disputed ownership."

Mah also rejected Singh's appeal of the lower court's decision not to award him costs, which he'd sought for a period he'd been caring for all four of the cats. He'd hired a cat-sitter to care for the animals while he was working out of town.

⚖️

Need a divorce in Alberta, Saskatchewan, or BC? Informed Paralegal can help! ⚖️
08/01/2025

Need a divorce in Alberta, Saskatchewan, or BC? Informed Paralegal can help! ⚖️

07/25/2025

📢 We’re updating Alberta’s tenancy law resources — and we need your input. 🏡

CPLEA is hosting 2-hour ONLINE community consultations from August to November.
These sessions are sector-specific, so please register for the one that best fits your role or organization.

Your feedback will directly shape the next generation of legal information for renters, landlords, and housing professionals across Alberta.

👉 To find out more about this project and register for a session, visit:
https://www.cplea.ca/what-we-do/community-consultations/

⭐️ Registrations close one week before each session date.

💬 Your voice matters. Help shape the future of tenancy law resources in Alberta!

Address

Airdrie, AB

Telephone

+18338493493

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Informed Paralegal Services posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Informed Paralegal Services:

Shortcuts

Share

Category