04/06/2026
In NSW, staying silent during a police interview is your right. But in some cases, that silence can be used against you at trial.
The Miranda Warning you see on American TV does not exist in NSW. What does exist is a right to silence that has become significantly more complicated since 2013.
Here is what you need to understand:
• Section 89 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) protects you from having a court draw negative conclusions from your silence during police questioning
• Section 89A creates an exception for serious indictable offences. If you stay silent and later raise a defence at trial that you did not mention to police, the court can treat that defence as a recent invention
• Section 89A only applies where a special caution is given in the presence of your lawyer. Understanding the difference between the standard caution and the special caution is essential
• Even innocent people can damage their case in a police interview. Getting a fact slightly wrong under pressure, such as the time or location of something, can be used to portray you as a liar
• Police do not have to tell you what evidence they already have. Staying silent prevents you from accidentally filling in the gaps for them
If police ask you to come in for a chat, do not go alone. The decisions made in the first hours of an investigation can shape the entire case.
National Criminal Lawyers advises clients on police interviews, right to silence, special cautions and criminal defence across NSW.
Read the full article: https://www.nationalcriminallawyers.com.au/beyond-the-miranda-myth-understanding-your-right-to-silence-in-nsw/