04/16/2025
đ§Ÿ Myth or Fact: Does Tort Reform Lower Insurance Premiums?Insurers claim that high premiums are caused by âgreedyâ attorneys and lawsuitsâand that tort reform is the solution.
But what does the data say?
đ Real-World Outcomes
Even aggressive reformsâlike caps on non-economic damagesâhave led to only 1â2% reductions in certain cases (NBER, 2009). State-level medical liability reforms have shown just 2â3% in savings (AAF, 2016).
States with little or no tort restrictions often have similar insurance rates to those with strict limits (Center for Justice & Democracy, 2024).
The Congressional Budget Office reports that the overall effect of tort reform on insurance premiums is mixed and not statistically significant (CBO, 2024).
U.S. auto insurance premiums rose 26% in 2024, with Louisiana leading at 32%âdespite passing limited tort reform in 2020 (S&P Global, 2024; Louisiana Illuminator, 2024).
Florida enacted sweeping changes in 2023 but still ranks among the most expensive states for both auto and home insurance (Newsweek, 2024).
âïž Are âGreedy Lawyersâ to Blame?
When policyholders sue insurers for bad faith, they must prove the insurer acted unreasonably, without proper cause, or even with malice (Cornell LII, 2024). These are not easy standards to meet.
Here are some real-world outcomes (there are many more):
USAA (2025): A Nevada jury awarded $114 millionâincluding $100 million in punitive damagesâfor bad faith claim handling (Insurance Business, 2025).
Progressive (2024): Reached a $48 million class action settlement with New York drivers over claims it undervalued totaled vehicles (Injury Claims, 2024).
State Farm (2013): Found liable for fraud after misclassifying wind damage from Hurricane Katrina as flood damageâshifting liability to the federal government (PBS, 2016).
American Reliable (2024): Ordered to pay $18 million for severely underpaying a valid storm damage claim (Public Law Library, 2024).
Juries can't award large verdicts for frivolous claims.
đïž The Role of Insurance Commissioners
In 2024, more than a dozen insurers exited states like Louisiana and California (Insurance Journal, 2024). Consumer advocates say weak oversight and lack of competition are key reasons for high premiums and fewer choices (Insurance Journal, 2024).
â
Bottom Line
You be the jurorâwhatâs really driving high premiums, and should tort reform be the answer?